Nier Replicant and Nier: Automata: Which game should I play first?

So you’ve heard about Nier Replicant or Nier: Automata, and you want to try the critically adored series. One problem: You don’t know where to start.

Relatable! The Nier series is notoriously dense, involving multiple endings, alternate versions of the original video game restricted by the geography of their release, and lore tied to an entirely different (and largely forgotten) video game trilogy for the PlayStation 2 and PlayStation 3. That’s intimidating.

To lower the barrier of entry, we’ve created this concise guide to choosing the order in which you play the Nier games, dividing our recommendation for three different types of potential players.

A screenshot of Nier: Automata in which 2B pets her robot pod

Image: PlatinumGames/Square Enix

I just wish to see what the fuss is about, and I only have so much time.

You should start with Nier: Automata. It is technically the sequel to Nier Replicant, but it builds upon the original game in every way. The combat is faster and more pleasurable, the story is easier to follow, and its alternate playthroughs change the game in dramatic ways. If you want to fall fast for the series, Automata has the best shot at winning you over.

If you love Automata, you may have more patience for Nier Replicant’s old-fashioned open world, slower pace, and more repetitive alternate playthroughs. On one hand, Nier: Automata will spoil some chunks of Replicant’s story. On the other hand, you’ll actually understand what the hell is going on.

Nier Replicant guide: Every side quest

Image: Toylogic/Square Enix via Polygon

I hate spoilers, I’m patient when it comes to older video game design, and I have some extra time on my hands.

You should begin with Nier Replicant, which is a remake of the 2010 cult video game of the same name. Well, sort of. In the U.S., we got Nier Gestalt, a version of Nier Replicant that featured an older protagonist. But the story of Gestalt was largely the same as in the version of Nier released for the PS3 in Japan, which features a teenage protagonist and is the basis of the remake.

Even with upgrades to the game’s visuals and combat, along with some additional quests and tradition, the remake of Nier Replicant (technically titled Nier Replicant ver.1.22474487139…) remains notably slower than Nier: Automata. The first 10 hours, in particular, can be a grind as you perform one fetch quest after another. But playing Replicant first will allow you to experience the series’ story as originally intended, seeing many of its weirdest twists and turns with fresh eyes.

Beginning with Replicant isn’t a bad option. In no way is it a crummy computer game. It’s simply a slow one. If you have the time and perseverance (or if you really dislike spoilers), then this is the choice for you.

A scene from Drakengard 3 involving stuff I don’t fully understand if I’m being super real with you.

Image: Access Games/Square Enix

No, you don’t get it. I truly dislike spoilers. I’m a completionist. I need to commune with art in its purest kind.

Play the Drakengard trilogy. Then return to me.

Jobber Wiki author Frank Long contributed to this report.